ALA Washington Office Chronology
INFORMATION ACCESS
American Library Association, Washington Office
1301 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 403
Washington, D.C. 20004 -1701
Tel: 202-628-8410 Fax: 202-628-8419 E-mail: alawash@alawash.org
http://www.ala.org/washoff
December 1998
Less Access to Less
Information By and About
THE U.S. Government: XXXI
A 1998 Chronology: June - December
Digitized by tlie Internet Arcliive
in 2010
http://www.archive.org/cletails/lessaccesstoless31amer
Less Access to Less Information By and About
THE U.S. Government: XXXI
A 1998 Chronology: June - December
CONTENTS
Introduction 4
June
Agencies Find It Difficult to Comply with Electronic
Freedom of Information Law 5
July
Thousands of Nixon Records Destroyed 5
CIA Breaks Promises to Release Cold War Files 5
FBI Exemption to Declassification Order Revealed 6
September
Sen. Moynihan Thinks Secrecy Is for Losers 6
October
Military Required to Remove Information from Public
Websites 7
House Members Angry at Secrecy Surrounding Huge
Omnibus Appropriations Bill 7
Automatic Declassification of Government
Documents Halted 8
Defense Department Blacks Out General Pinochet
Biographic Sketch 8
November
CIA Refuses to Reveal Names of Human Rights Violators .... 8
Switch from Paper to Electronic Distribution of 2000
Census Data Raises Information Issues 8
EPA Decides to Withhold Disaster Information from the
Internet 9
Supreme Court Stops Case Because of Secrecy 9
Controversy Could Lead to Less Accurate Census 10
December
Annual Report on Declassification Identifies Lingering
Problems 10
Nixon Papers Controversy Continues in New Trail 10
Federal Agency Holds Secret Information about Princess
Diana 1 1
Democrats and Republicans Clash over FBI Documents II
CIA Fights Release of Budget Information 1 1
OPENNESS — Some examples are also
AVAILABLE ABOUT "MORE AcCESS" DURING THIS
SAME period:
June
Secret Navy Data Declassified 12
The FBI Makes Secrets Available on the Internet 12
Patent Database to Be Freely Available on the Internet 12
July
Tobacco Documents Made More Accessible to the Public 12
Judge Tells FDA Not to Block Drug Data 13
August
Bill Would Open Nazi Records 13
Declassification Ordered of Selected Cold War Documents.... 13
September
JFK Assassination Records Released 13
October
Head of CIA Publications Review Board Takes Pride In
What He Has "Left In" 14
National Security Archive Mounts Collection of
Declassified Documents 14
November
National Archives Becomes Trove of Declassified World
War II Documents 14
The COGI James Madison Awards honor
champions of the public's right to know 15
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 3
Less Access to Less Information By and About
THE U.S. Government: XXXI
A 1998 Chronology: June - December
Introduction
For the past 17 years, this ongoing selective
chronology has documented efforts to
restrict and privatize government information.
It is distributed at ALA's Midwinter and
Annual Conferences and as an electronic
publication at http://www.ala.org/washoff/
lessaccess.html. While government
information is more accessible through
computer networks and the Freedom of
Information Act, there are still barriers to
public access. Disclosure that federal
agencies are failing to make public
information available on their World Wide
Web sites or withdrawing it for security
reasons raises concerns about public access to
government information in the present and
future.
Another development, with major
implications for public access, is the growing
tendency of federal agencies to use computer
and telecommunication technologies for data
collection, storage, retrieval, and
dissemination. This trend has resulted in the
increased emergence of contractual
arrangements with commercial firms to
disseminate information collected at taxpayer
expense, higher user charges for government
information, and the proliferation of
government information available in
electronic format only. This trend toward
electronic dissemination is occurring in all
three branches of government. While
automation clearly offers promises of savings,
will public access to government information
be further restricted for people who cannot
afford computers or pay for computer time?
On the other hand, the Government Printing
Office GPO Access system and the Library of
Congress THOMAS system have enhanced
public access by providing free online access
to government databases.
Recognizing that some federal agencies are
succeeding in increasing public access to
government information, this update also
includes selected examples of such successes.
ALA continues to reaffirm its long-standing
conviction that open government is vital to a
democracy. A January 1984 resolution passed
by ALA's Council stated that "there should be
equal and ready access to data collected,
compiled, produced, and published in any
format by the government of the United
States."
In 1986, ALA initiated a Coalition on
Government Information. The Coalition's
objectives are to focus national attention on
all efforts that limit access to government
information, and to develop support for
improvements in access to government
information. Since 1989, the Coalition has
presented the James Madison Award to
champions of the public's right to know. The
awardees are listed in this update.
With access to information a major ALA
priority, library advocates should be
concerned about barriers to public access to
government information. Previous
chronologies were compiled in two ALA
Washington Office indexed publications, Less
Access to Less Information By and About the
U.S. Government: A 1981-1987 Chronology,
and Less Access to Less Information By and
About the U.S. Government: A 1988-1991
Chronology. The following selected
chronology continues the tradition of a semi-
annual update. ♦
4 • ALA Washington Office
Chronology
June
Agencies Find It Difficult to Comply with
Electronic Freedom of Information Law
Backlogs in processing traditional paper-based
requests under the Freedom of Information Act are
hindering some federal agencies from complying
with the requirements of the 1996 Electronic
Freedom of Information Act. At a hearing of the
House Subcommittee on Government
Management, Information and Technology, chaired
by Rep. Steve Horn (R-CA), a FBI spokesman said
the agency has a backlog of nearly 1 1,900 requests
for information. Technical difficulties in Web site
development have also stymied agencies from
EFOIA compliance, said Richard Huff, co-director
of the Justice Department's Office of Information
and Privacy.
Patrice McDermott of OMB Watch, an
organization that monitors public access to
government records, said that of the 57 federal
agencies her organization had surveyed recently,
none had complied fully with EFOIA. She cited
three reasons for the lack of compliance: lack of
Congressional funding, lack of guidance to
agencies from the Office of Management and
Budget, and the failure of agencies to make access
to federal information a priority. "The goal of
EFOIA should be to make so much information
publicly available online that Freedom of
Information Act requests become an avenue of last
resort," McDermott said. (Tillett, L. Scott. "Feds
find EFOIA a tough act to follow," Federal
Computer Week, June 15, 1998, 18.)
July
Thousands of Nixon Records Destroyed
In early June the National Archives and Records
Administration shredded more than 70,000 pages
of documents about former President Richard M.
Nixon. Then the shreds were stuffed into 126 burn
bags and incinerated at the Pentagon. The
records, not classified or related to national
security, were logs summing up what have been
deemed to be "private/personal" or
"private/political" conversations on the former
president's White House tapes. The documents
were covered by a federal court order that requires
the Archives to return to the Nixon estate all the
"personal and private" conversations scattered
throughout his original White House tapes.
Archivist John Carlin is trying to decide what to
do with the fragile, original tapes. It is estimated
that it would take five years to edit the 3,700 hours
of tape. Additionally trying to edit out the 819
hours of "personal" discussions would probably
destroy most of the original tapes including
segments concerning the Watergate scandal.
Some archival specialists suggest a bonfire for the
original tapes, too. "Cutting and splicing them is
going to be a monumental waste of time," one said.
"Once you start cutting, you've destroyed the
tapes." (Lardner, George. "Nixon Logs Burn to
Ashes," The Washington Post, July 1, 1998, A21.)
[Ed. Note: Previous chronologies reported on
earlier developments about the Nixon tapes.]
CIA Breaks Promises to Release Cold War Files
Citing lack of funds and personnel, George Tenet,
director of the Central Intelligence Agency,
announced that the agency will not release secret
records about most of its major cold war covert
operations in the foreseeable future. The CIA
promised five years ago to declassify thousands of
files on 1 1 major paramilitary and political
operations carried out under Presidents Truman,
Eisenhower and Kennedy. Some documents from
two of the operations have been published: the
1961 Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba and the 1954
coup against the Guatemalan government. But
Tenet's statement made it clear that the agency
never undertook a serious effort to declassify the
remaining nine operations.
Information about the nine operations make up a
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 5
secret history of American power used against
foreign government. The CIA also promised six
years ago to release records of its coup in Iran in
1954. It belatedly acknowledged last year that
most of those files had been destroyed in the
1960s. Tenet said the CIA had released 227,000
pages to a government panel on the assassination
of President Kennedy and reams of information for
the official histories of the State Department of the
1950s and 1960s. These releases took precedence
over the voluntary effort to declassify covert
actions.
Page Putnam Miller, director of the National
Coordinating Committee for the Promotion of
History, said, "There are no resources now for this
project." A CIA spokeswoman said about 150
people work on declassification, handling requests
from the White House, Congress, State
Department, and requests under the Freedom of
Information Act. She said the amount of money
spent on the effort could not be revealed because it
was secret. ("Weiner, Tim. "CIA, Breaking
Promises, Put Off Release of Cold War Files," The
New York Times, July 15, 1998, A13.)
FBI Exemption to Declassification Order
Revealed
In 1995 when President Clinton signed an
executive order directing the automatic
declassification of millions of government secrets
more than 25 years old, he did not mention that the
Federal Bureau of Information would have a
blanket exemption. FBI officials defended the
previously undisclosed exemption, saying it was
essential because of the size of its files — 6.5
million cubic feet — where classified and
unclassified files are mingled, often without labels
that show those supposed to concern national
security. No other government agency, including
the CIA and the super-secret National Security
Agency, won an exemption. "It sounds like we
pulled a real coup," one FBI agent said.
The arrangement came to light in court papers in
June and was laid out in detail in a memo obtained
by The Washington Post under the Freedom of
Information Act. Critics of government secrecy
said that the exemption was legally questionable
because it has no cut-off date and because the FBI
used federal privacy law instead of any national
security concerns to justify it. It is uncertain how
and why the special arrangement for the FBI came
about. "The understanding was that there was a
distinction between making something public and
removing any classification from it," said former
National Security Council staff member Morton
Halperin. "These files were not going to be
automatically put in a public library after 25 years.
They would still be subject to law enforcement and
privacy reviews. So therefore this [automatic
declassification] was not a big threat to them."
(Lardner, George. "FBI Won Exception to
Presidential Order Declassifying Secrets," The
Washington Post, July 19, 1998, A03.)
September
Sen. Moynihan Thinks Secrecy Is for Losers
In his book. Secrecy: The American Experience,
Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D-NY) offered
advice to public officials considering whether or
not to keep information confidential: When in
doubt, put it out. Moynihan drew on the work of
the Commission on Protecting and Reducing
Government Secrecy (1995-97), which he chaired,
to write a history of official secrecy in America.
Moynihan wrote that a case can be made that
secrecy is for losers — both people and policies.
He asserted that Richard Nixon's rage at the
publication of the top-secret Pentagon Papers in
1971 eventually led to the Watergate break-in and
ultimately his resignation. Additionally, he
believes that the covert Bay of Pigs fiasco in 1961
"arguably led to the Cuban missile crisis of 1962,"
the most dangerous moment of the Cold War.
Moynihan argued that overclassification stifles
analysis and debate (the reason the CIA did not
foresee the collapse of the Soviet Union); it deters
self-criticism that is fundamental to democracy;
and its feeds suspicions of conspiracy. He said that
the benefits of publication are rarely weighed when
classifiers v/orry about the harm that may result
from disclosure of information. Knowledge is
6 • ALA Washington Office
power, Moynihan concluded, and if other people
have less knowledge, the official has more power.
(Turner, Robert L. "Putting the Word Out on
'Secrecy,'" The Boston Globe, September 29, 1998,
C2.)
October
Military Required to Remove Information from
Public Web Sites
Deputy Secretary of Defense John Hamre issued a
directive on September 25 requiring all Department
of Defense organizations to remove certain
information from public military Web sites. Plans
for military operations, movements of military
units and personal data such as Social Security
numbers, phone numbers and addresses of military
personnel family members were included. The
threat of terror attacks against military people and
installations was the justification for the directive.
The impact of the directive was not immediately
clear since few, if any, military Web sites have
content that has not cleared for release. However,
the new directive might make it more difficult to
decide what may be released. Among the materials
that may go under wraps are maps, biographies of
and speeches by civilian officials. "By looking at
various speeches, you might find that the person
might reference his parents and where they live," a
spokesman said. "If you connect bios with the
speeches, you could get personal information about
civilian officials." However, removing maps from
Web sites would not do much for security because
maps appear in guidebooks that are available to the
public. The Defense Department recognizes that
the information on its Web sites is public
information and that the public could obtain it by
going to a military installation or filing a Freedom
of Information Act. But making information so
easily accessible on the Internet concerns Defense
officials.
Internet freedom advocates expressed concern
that officials may use threats to personnel as an
excuse to keep legitimate information from the
public. "If this is taken as an excuse to take out
budget information, information on weapons
systems, and so on it would be a travesty on the
American people," said William Arkin, an
independent defense analyst. The Pentagon's main
Web site (at http://www.defenselink.mil) branches
into separate Web sites for each military branch
and some individual units and ships. Some bases
have independent sites. (Ratnam, Gopal. "Defense
Reviews Sensitivity of Web Site Data," Federal
Times, October 12, 1998, 4.)
House Members Angry at Secrecy Surrounding
Huge Omnibus Appropriations Bill
Numerous rank and file Members of Congress
criticized the House leadership for secretly stuffing
millions of dollars in controversial projects into the
$520 billion omnibus appropriations bill that was
prepared as the 105th Congress moved toward
adjournment. Republicans were angered when
their leadership blocked them from examining the
details of the pending funding legislation. "We
have negotiated a bill we can't read with people we
don't trust and spent money we don't have for
things we don't need," Rep. Steve Largent (R-OK)
said of the funding bill that passed the House on
October 20. Republicans were particularly angry
with Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich (R-GA)
and Appropriations Chair Robert Livingston (R-
LA) for allegedly "hiding" the details of the 40-
pound, 4,000-page bill until just hours before the
final vote.
On the Senate side. Sen. John McCain (R-AZ)
said, "The process by which the bill was created is
deplorable. Negotiations were conducted behind
closed doors, out of sight of the public as well as
the vast majority of Members of Congress.
Decisions were made and then reversed without
notice." Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D-NY)
criticized Congressional leaders for writing nearly
one-third of the $1.7 trillion budget behind closed
doors. "We are beginning to resemble a kind of
bastard parliamentary system in which the real
decisions are made in a closed room by three or
four people," he said. Republicans were equally
infuriated that the budget plan was available for
only a few to see. (VandeHei, Jim and Ethan
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 7
Wallison. "Budget Fight Ends, But Few Are
Happy," Roll Call, October 22, 1998, 1.)
Automatic Declassification of Government
Documents Halted
Automatic declassification of classified records
more than 25 years old was halted by a provision
inserted into the defense authorization bill for
FY1999 (P.L. 105-261). Decried by critics as a
major blow to secrecy reform, the law directs
government agencies to revert to a page-by-page
review of all classified records more than 25 years
old. This painstaking and time consuming review
is required until the Department of Energy and the
National Archives develop procedures determining
which of their documents are "highly unlikely" to
contain "Restricted Data" or "Formerly Restricted
Date," as nuclear secrets are called.
As he signed H.R. 3616, President Clinton
stated: "I am disappointed that the Congress, in a
well-meaning effort to further protect nuclear
weapons information, has included an overly broad
provision that impedes my Administration's work
to declassify historically valuable records. I am
committed to submitting the plan required under
this Act within 90 days. In the meantime, I will
interpret this provision in a manner that will assure
the maximum continuity of agency efforts, as
directed by my Executive Order 12958, to
declassify historically valuable records." (Miller,
Page Putnam. "President Critical of Restrictive
Declassification Provision in Defense
Authorization Act," NCC Washington Update, vol.
4, no. 42, October 26, 1998 [http://www.h-net.msu.
edu/~ncc/].)
Defense Department Blacks Out General
Pinochet Biographic Sketch
When the U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency
released a biographic sketch of General Augusto
Pinochet, it blacked out everything on the page
other than the date, his name, and his position as
the President and Chief of the Military Junta in
Chile. The document, released under the Freedom
of Information Act, is one page of thousands of
secret documents buried in Washington. A picture
of the black page was featured in The New York
Times. (Kornbluh, Peter. "Op-Art: Defense
Intelligence Agency," The New York Times,
October 26, 1998, A25.)
November
CIA Refuses to Reveal Names of Human Rights
Violators
In a newly declassified report written by its
inspector general, the Central Intelligence Agency
refused to give human rights investigators in
Honduras the names of Honduran military officers
suspected of executing a leader of
counterinsurgency operations in 1983. Despite
deletions, the report acknowledged for the first
time that the CIA knew at the time of "death
squad" activities linked to Honduran military
personnel with whom the U.S. government had
close ties. The report also acknowledged that CIA
officials failed to fully reveal the extent of human
rights violations in Honduras to agency
headquarters or to Congress.
The agency's deletions of names again ignited a
debate over legislation that would have required
the CIA to disclose information even if it revealed
the identity of confidential intelligence sources.
The Senate narrowly defeated legislation that
would have prohibited the CIA from withholding
information about an individual's involvement in
human rights abuses "solely because that individual
was or is an intelligence source." The bill also
established an expedited declassification process
for documents sought by human rights
investigators in Honduras and Guatemala and
created a panel to review declassification decisions
made by the CIA. (Loeb, Vernon. "CIA Won't
Name Hondurans Suspected of Executing Rebel,"
The Washington Post, November 4, 1998, A2.)
Switch from Paper to Electronic Distribution of
2000 Census Data Raises Information Issues
The Census Bureau is planning to mount most of
the 2000 census data on the Internet, with little
8 • ALA Washington Office
being distributed in paper. Although the plan is
likely to result in a profusion of private-sector
packaging of government information, there
appears to be little concern about whether the
quality and veracity of government data could be
compromised by marketers who may enhance the
materials in their zeal to tailor it for business
clients. Others express concerns about the Internet
being used as the primary method for
disseminating federal statistics without a national
policy for cyberspace information storage and
retrieval. "What the Census Bureau is doing is just
the tip of a much bigger iceberg," said Gary Bass,
executive director of OMB Watch, an organization
that monitors public access to government records.
"The government doesn't have a plan for regulating
its data. [Federal officials] can't, or shouldn't, be
putting it out there willy-nilly because what they
are releasing affects us all."
Although some experts worry about policy
implications, entrepreneurs are eager to download
information produced by the Census Bureau,
repackage it, and sell it at a profit. Mike Bergman,
a Census Bureau spokesman, said, "The idea is to
put this new system in place and allow people to
do the sophisticated number-crunching themselves
online." Bureau officials said their Web site
(http://www.census.gov) is already among the most
popular in the world. Don Wynegar, chief of
marketing services at the bureau said, "Once we
have the data up on our Web site, it will generate
opportunities for middlemen to repackage the data
and sell it. Millions of people who have access to
the Internet will be able to dial us up. There will
be numerous vendors looking for ways to use the
materials. We're giving it away." (Fulwood, Sam.
"U.S. Counting on Web to Be Census Source Data:
Bureau Plans to Post Most of Its 2000 Enumeration
Data on the Internet." Los Angeles Times, Home
Edition, November 15, 1998, 28.)
EPA Decides to Withhold Disaster Information
from the Internet
The 1990 Clean Air Act requires facilities that use
large amounts of extremely hazardous substances
to prepare Risk Management Plans (RMP),
including worst-case accident scenarios. The
Environmental Protection Agency, which
implements the law, has decided not to proceed
with a plan to put the complete scenarios on the
Internet. Intense pressure from Congress, law-
enforcement agencies and the chemical industry
apparently caused the change in policy. EPA said
that it had been eager to place the disaster
scenarios on the Internet, but now it will post some
basic information about chemicals at the plants,
including which chemicals are being stored and
used and emergency-response plans for those
places. Some Members of Congress, the FBI, and
the CIA opposed the plan, maintaining that broadly
available disaster information could be used by
terrorists. Environmental groups said the publicly
accessible database would help Americans identify
threats in their backyards, and that the more public
information that is available about chemicals in
neighborhoods, the more pressure there will be to
reduce the use of these chemicals. (Borenstein,
Seth. "EPA Keeps Data on Disaster Scenarios Off
Internet," The Philadelphia Inquirer, November 19,
1998, A13.)
Supreme Court Stops Case Because of Secrecy
On November 2 the Supreme Court declined to
hear two cases brought by employees at a top-
secret Air Force base near Groom Lake, NV. The
plaintiffs, former workers and two widows of men
who worked at the base, claim they were exposed
to high levels of hazardous waste. A district court
had dismissed the cases, finding that a trial would
be impossible because of the Air Force's right to
keep secret national security information. Among
the secret information the Defense Department, the
co-defendant with the Environmental Protection
Agency, was allowed to withhold from the
plaintiffs was whether hazardous materials were
generated, stored or disposed of at the base known
as Area 51. Both widows claimed that the death of
their husbands was job-related. The case is Stella
Kasza et al. vs. EPA et ai, 98-5405, U.S. Supreme
Court, November 2, 1998. (Harris, Christy.
"Secrecy Stops Widows' Claims," Federal Times,
November 23, 1998,4.)
Less Access • June - December 1998
Controversy Could Lead to Less Accurate
Census
Controversy continues to surround the method of
counting the population to be used in the 2000
census. Trying to correct an undercount of about 4
million people in the 1990 census, Census Bureau
officials have planned to use statistical sampling to
reduce the disproportionate undercount of racial
minorities in the 2000 census. Some members of
the Census Monitoring Board, a congressionally-
appointed bipartisan board, have suggested the
Census Bureau eliminate "scientific sampling"
from the 2000 census by using Medicaid, food
stamp, driver's license and similar files. Resisting
the suggestion. Census Bureau officials said that
for years they have been testing the feasibility of
gathering, matching and verifying data from
federal, state and local agencies. They have found
that some state officials fail to release needed
records, and files they could use with special
permission often were dated, error-riddled and
incomplete for census use. Officials said relying
extensively on administrative records would raise
costs and take more time than the agency now has.
For various reasons some Members of Congress
and others oppose sampling, which the Census
Bureau says would be more accurate and less
costly than the traditional methods. Additionally,
sampling twice has been ruled illegal. These
rulings have been appealed and the Supreme Court
heard arguments on sampling's legality on
November 30. Justices are expected to rule on the
issues by July 1999. The cases are Department of
Commerce vs. House of Representatives, No. 98-
404, and Clinton vs. Glavin, No. 98-564. (Gribbin,
August. "Census officials see problems with
suggestion to use files," The Washington Times,
November 24, 1998, A4.)
December
Annual Report on Declassification Identifies
Lingering Problems
At the end of August, the Information Security
Office released its annual report for FY 1997
concerning its implementation of Executive Order
12958 on national security policy and
declassification of government records. Although
positive trends were highlighted, it also identified
lingering problems.
The report said start-up and compliance among
the major classifying agencies has been uneven.
Additionally, the rate of declassification at several
agencies is lagging because of an apparent
unwillingness to alter an extremely cautious
approach to declassification. Several agencies will
not declassify any information that has not
undergone a line-by-line review by several
reviewers, notwithstanding the age of the
documents or their subject matter. Resource
limitations are having a clear impact on agency
compliance and oversight. In some instances,
declassification activity has been so prolific that it
exceeds the ability of agency systems and
resources to process the records for public access,
or even the ability to advise other agencies and the
public about what information has been
declassified. The "Information Security Oversight
Office: 1997 Report to the President" is available
at the Web site of the Federal of American
Scientists at http://www.fas.org/sgp/isoo/
isoo97.html (Miller, Page Putnam. NCC
Washington Update, vol. 4, no. 46, December 1,
1998).
Nixon Papers Controversy Continues in New
Trail
A long-delayed trial to determine the "just
compensation" due to former President Nixon's
estate opened in a federal court. The Nixon
lawyers say that the former president's White
House tapes and papers have a "fair market value"
of up to $213 million dollars. Government lawyers
sought to show that Nixon never intended to sell
10 • ALA Washington Office
them and could not have done so without years of
laborious processing. A Nixon attorney said that
Congress abrogated an agreement to donate his
records to the National Archives when Congress
passed a law in 1974 confiscating Nixon's records
and thwarting his hopes of having them housed in
a traditional presidential library. Congress acted to
prevent Nixon from destroying his tapes and to
provide the public "with the full truth" about the
abuses of power that forced him from office.
(Lardner, George. "Nixon Agreement on Donating
Papers Cited," The Washington Post, December 4,
1998, AlO.)
Federal Agency Holds Secret Information about
Princess Diana
In the process of denying a Freedom of
Information Act request, the National Security
Agency revealed that it had a 1,056-page file on
the late Princess Diana. An NSA spokesperson
said that the documents had been classified top
secret "because their disclosure could reasonably
be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage
to the national security."
The super-secret spy agency was involved in an
additional controversy in Europe. Last January a
report released by the European Parliament
concluded, "within Europe, all e-mail, telephone
and fax communications are routinely intercepted
by the United States National Security Agency."
The report focused on a system called Echelon
through which NSA and its spy partners in Britain,
Canada, New Zealand and Australia share
communications intercepted world-wide and divide
the huge task of analyzing the "take." "Each of the
five [countries] supply 'dictionaries' to the other
four of keywords, phrases, people and places to
'tag,' and the tagged intercept is forwarded straight
to the requesting country," according to the report.
Steven Aftergood, of the Federation of American
Scientists, said he could not understand why the
Echelon controversy has gone unnoticed in the
United States. He acknowledged that the lack of
interest might result from the fact that law
prohibits NSA from targeting American citizens
for communications intercepts, here or abroad.
(Loeb, Vernon. "NSA Admits to Holding Secret
Information On Princess Diana," The Washington
Post, December 12, 1998, A13.)
Democrats and Republicans Clash over FBI
Documents
Democratic Members of Congress have accused
Republican Judiciary Committee members of
trying to increase support for President Clinton's
impeachment based on unproven and "misleading"
information. The materials at issue are sealed FBI
documents containing unsubstantiated allegations
about the President that were not included in the
public material accompanying Independent
Counsel Kenneth Starr's report to Congress.
Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee
were furious over the inspections of the sealed
documents. They accused Republicans of
circulating unfounded rumors about the president
and of failing to tell Democrats that the sealed
documents were available in an area for "secured"
information in the Gerald R. Ford congressional
building. Jim Jordan, spokesman for the
Committee's Democrats, said, "The material was
withheld of the committee... because it's
unsubstantiated, ambiguous and misleading."
Sam Stratman, spokesman for Committee Chair
Henry Hyde (R-IL), said the inspections to the
sealed documents were proper. He added that
when the House formally created its impeachment
inquiry in October, it granted every member access
to all the documents accumulated by Starr,
including those not made public. (Goldstein, Amy
and Juliet Eilperin. "Democrats, GOP Clash over
FBI Documents," The Washington Post, December
19, 1998, A36.)
CIA Fights Release of Budget Information
A Washington Post editorial criticized the Central
Intelligence Agency for actively opposing a lawsuit
requesting the CIA's intelligence budget request for
1999. The editorial encouraged the CIA to
reconsider its position, arguing that "the
government's unwillingness to disclose the budget
request smacks of reflexive government secrecy
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 11
and of an unreadiness of the agency to subject
itself to the most rudimentary pubHc
accountabiUty."
In 1997 and 1998 the CIA did release aggregated
intelligence budget information in response to a
Freedom of Information Act lawsuit by the
Federation of American Scientists. In 1996 the
bipartisan Commission on the Roles and
Capabilities of the United States Intelligence
Community recommended that the disclosure of
both budget requests and appropriations every year
could be done "in a manner that does not raise a
significant security concern."
CIA Director George J. Tenet filed a statement
opposing this latest lawsuit, stating that disclosure
of the 1999 figures, along with previously
disclosed figures for 1997 and 1998, "provides a
measure of the administration's unique critical
assessment of its own intelligence programs."
Tenet also argued that release of such budget
information "reasonably could be expected to cause
damage to the national security and would tend to
reveal intelligence sources and methods." ("A CIA
Secret," The Washington Post, December 28, 1998,
A24.)
OPENNESS: Some Examples
are also available about
"More Access" during this
SAME period:
June
Secret Navy Data Declassified
Vice President Gore announced the declassification
and release of secret and restricted Navy data. The
data, of scientific and commercial value, will help
increase public understanding of marine life,
improve weather forecasting and climate change
research, and identify valuable ocean resources.
Additionally, the Department of Defense will
improve marine safety by producing computer-
based nautical charts to replace the paper charts
used by mariners for centuries. (White House Press
Release. "Public Access to Military Data and
Technology," June 12, 1998.)
The FBI Makes Secrets Available on the
Internet
The FBI quiedy posted more than 1,600 pages
dating back to the 1940s on its Web site
(http://www.fbi.gov/), although most contain
blacked-out passages and missing names. The
agency plans to put up to 1.3 million documents
online, including some on famous people,
unidentified flying objects, and alleged alien
abductions. (Macavinta, Courtney. "FBI posts the
real "X files," CNET News.Com, June 19, 1998,
[http://www.news.com/News/Item/
0,4,233343,00.html].)
Patent Database to Be Freely Available on the
Internet
The Clinton Administration announced that it
would make the full database of United States
patents since 1976 and trademark text and images
starting from the late 1800s freely available on
Internet at http://www.uspto.gov/. The project will
create the largest online government database,
made up of more than 21 million documents. This
decision will fuel the fierce debate between public
interest advocates who argue that government
information should be available electronically and
commercial companies that purchase the data from
government agencies to resell for a profit. ("U.S.
Plans Free Public Access to Patent Database on the
Web," San Jose Mercury News, June 25, 1998,
4C.)
July
Tobacco Documents Made More Accessible to
the Public
Important information about the health hazards of
tobacco and the tobacco industry's effort to induce
children to smoke were hidden by the industry for
decades. President Clinton directed Secretary of
12 • ALA Washington Office
Health and Human Services Donna E. Shalala to
coordinate a public health review of tobacco
industry documents and develop a plan to make the
documents more accessible to researchers and the
public at large. The plan would: (1) propose a
method for coordinating review of the documents
and making available an easily searchable index
and/or digest of the reviewed documents; (2)
propose a plan to disseminate widely the index
and/or digest as well as the documents themselves,
including expanded use of the Internet; and (3)
provide a strategy for coordinating a broad public
and private review and analysis of the documents
to gain critical public health information. (White
House Press Release. "President Clinton Makes
Tobacco Documents More Accessible to the
Public," July 17, 1998.)
Judge Tells FDA Not to Block Drug Data
U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth ruled that the
Food and Drug Administration's ban on the
distribution to doctors of scientific journal articles
and textbooks violates constitutional protections
for commercial speech. At issue is medical
information concerning unapproved uses for
pharmaceutical companies' products. FDA
officials argued that the ban is necessary to ensure
that companies do not promote products by
providing incomplete or biased information, or
gain approval for a drug for a narrow use and then
promote many other uses through the distribution
of favorable scientific information. The Clinton
Administration is likely to appeal the ruling.
(Schwartz, John. "FDA Is Told Not to Block Drug
Data," The Washington Post, July 31, 1998, A23.)
August
Bill Would Open Nazi Records
Congress passed S. 1379, The Nazi War Crimes
Disclosure Act, establishing the Nazi War Criminal
Interagency Working Group to locate, identify,
inventory, recommend for declassification, and
make available to the public all classified Nazi war
criminal records of the United States. The Act will
make it much easier for historians, researchers and
the public to view the documents dating to the
Cold War years that followed World War II.
Several federal agencies, including the CIA, the
State Department and the Department of Defense,
refused to declassify the documents, citing national
security. (Associated Press. "Bill Would Open
Nazi Crimes Files," The Boston Globe, August 7,
1998, A14.)
[Ed. Note: The President signed PL. ] 05-246 on
Octobers, 1998. J
Declassification Ordered of Selected Cold War
Documents
A report from the Interagency Security
Classification Appeals Panel showed that the panel
reversed agency decisions and declassified Cold
War records more than 80 percent of the time.
Information was declassified in full or in part in 81
out of the 96 documents presented to it, while
agency classification actions were upheld in the
case of 15 documents. ISCAP was established in
1995 when President Clinton signed Executive
Order 12958, the first effort since the end of the
Cold War to reassess the balance between open
government and the need to maintain secrets vital
to national security. The panel resolves appeals
from Executive Branch classification decisions,
and can be reached by e-mail at
iscap@archl.nara.gov. (White House Press
Release. "Federal Panel Orders Declassification of
Selected Cold War Documents," August 26, 1998.)
September
JFK Assassination Records Released
The Assassination Records Review Board released
its final report in late September after releasing
thousands of previously secret government records
about the assassination of President Kennedy.
Because the Board decided to interpret an
"assassination record" very broadly, the documents
reveal significant new insights into Cold War
foreign policy and how some agencies operated
during crises. For historians, the value of this
federal undertaking was seen not only in the
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 13
released documents, but also in the broad
implications of openness for declassification
policy.
While the Board weighed the public's right to
know with the need to protect sensitive national
security information, statute mandated a
"presumption of disclosure." Agency heads could
only appeal to the President to keep closed those
records that the Board decided should be kept
open. The Final Report of the Assassination
Records Review Board is available from the
Government Printing Office (S/N 05200301472-6,
$24) or online at http://fedbbs.access.gpo.gov/
libs/arrb_pdf.htm (Miller, Page. "Assassination
Records Review Board Issues Final Report with
Recommendations for Increasing Openness," NCC
Washington Update. September 30, 1998.)
October
Head of CIA Publications Review Board Takes
Pride In What He Has "Left In"
John Hollister Hedley heads the five-member
publications review board that decides what former
employees of the Central Intelligence Agency can
publish about the agency. He hates to be called a
censor, but his job is to decide how much the CIA
will permit to be revealed about the inner workings
of the agency. He has even cut information from a
cookbook of recipes prepared by CIA agents and
their spouses.
During the past three years, Hedley has
distinguished himself by what he has left in, not by
what he has taken out. He has helped establish
new standards of openness that have allowed
former spies, analysts and agency officials to go
farther than ever before in describing their
clandestine careers. "I think we need to open up,
and I think we can have it both ways," said Hedley.
"I do not think you endanger the protection of that
which needs to be protected while you open up and
are much more transparent than we've been, in
terms of what kind of people we are, and what we
do, and how we do it." (Loeb, Vernon. "Drawing
the Company's Line," The Washington Post,
October 13, 1998, A13.)
National Security Archive Mounts Collection of
Declassified Documents
The world's largest non-governmental collection of
declassified documents is the National Security
Archive Web site (http://www.seas.gwu.edu/
nsarchive/). The National Security Archive, an
independent non-governmental research institute
and library located at The George Washington
University in Washington, D.C, collects and
publishes declassified documents acquired through
the Freedom of Information Act. It has assembled
a particularly impressive collection documenting
government misadventures in Latin America over
the past four decades. Other topics range from
nuclear weaponry and the militarization of space to
the White House meeting of President Nixon and
Elvis Presley. (Futrell, David. "Top Secret
Documents Put Starr's Stuff to Shame." Newsday,
October 18, 1998, B15.)
November
National Archives Becomes Trove of
Declassified World War II Documents
Recently declassified National Archives documents
from the World War II era could provide a rich
source of clues for researchers, historians and
politicians as to what happened to Jewish assets
and bank accounts in the United States during and
after the war. The creation of the U.S. Holocaust
Assets Presidential Advisory Commission and the
Clinton Administration's plans to declassify
additional American intelligence records have
added additional hope that bringing together
scattered declassified documents that may lead to
long-lost fortunes: plundered gold and assets of
conquered countries and slain victims, as well as
the unclaimed bank accounts, assets and insurance
policies of Nazi victims. (Howe, Desson. "A
Wealth of New Information on Holocaust," The
Washington Post, November 18, 1998, BOl.)
14 • ALA Washington Office
The COGI James Madison Awards
honor champions of the public's right to know
The James Madison Award, presented annually by the CoaHtion on Government Information, honors
those who have championed, protected and promoted pubHc access to government information and the
pubHc's right to know. It is presented on Freedom of Information Day, March 16, the anniversary of
the birth date of President James Madison. The CoaHtion on Government Information was estabhshed
by the American Library Association in 1986. The Coalition's 50 member organizations share a
concern for loss of pubHc access to federal government information.
Recipients of the James Madison Award:
1998 Ben Bagdikian, journalist
Wayne P. Kelley, former Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office
Eliot Christian and the U.S. Geological Survey
National Library of Medicine
1997 Philanthropist and financier George Soros
1996 The National Information Infrastructure Advisory Council
1995 The Government Printing Office, the State of Maryland's Sailor Project, the Seattle
(WA) Public Library, and the Internet Multicasting Service's Town Hall Project
1994 Secretary of Energy Hazel O'Leary and former ALA Washington Office Director Eileen
D. Cooke
1993 The legislators who led the passage of PL. 103-40, the GPO Access Act: Vice President
Al Gore, original sponsor of the GPO Gateway to Government Act when he was in the
Senate; Senators Wendell Ford (D-KY) and Ted Stevens (R-AK); Representatives
Charlie Rose (D-NC) and Bill Thomas (R-CA)
1992 Journalist Nina Totenberg, author Scott Armstrong, and C-SPAN founder Brian Lamb
1991 Representative Don Edwards (D-CA)
1990 Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ), Representative Henry Waxman (D-CA), journalist
Philip Shabecoff , and the Office of Toxic Substances of the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency
1989 Senator Patrick Leahy (D-VT)
Honorary citations also were presented to several individuals and organizations in 1996 and 1997.
The Coalition seeks nominations for the annual James Madison Award and for honorary citations
in December of each year. Send nominations to:
Coalition on Government Information
c/o American Library Association
Washington Office tel: 800-941-8478
1301 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 403 ^^^* 202-628-8419
Washington, D.C. 20004-1701 e-mail: alawash@alawash.org
Less Access • June - December 1998 • 15